Although it’s doubtful I’ll be using “Draw Me Close to You” in the near future (we use tons of Indelible Grace, Getty, and Sovereign Grace), I think it’s dangerous to make the kind of statements Colson makes. First, how dare we have requirements for song lyrics that the Psalmist himself couldn’t stack up to! Second, to make mention of specific songs, in the manner Colson did, by no means reflects the love of Christ that should bind His people together.
Simplistic proclamations deeming some songs as shallow and some not are not helpful. Regarding simple love songs, often the how is as important as the what. If we’re stringing together scores of sentimental, shallow songs to form a complete worship service, that’s not wise. Imagine if you just talked in sappy, baby speech to your wife all the time. Using a simple song in the context of several theologically rich songs, however, can be quite moving. For example, Chris Tomlin’s “How Great Is Our God” is a simple, yet God-centered, song. Placed at the end of a song service, perhaps following “How Great Thou Art,” results in a moving, fitting response to God’s greatness.
Colson is right that much of evangelicalism sings baby talk to God in her songs. He is wrong to say that there is never an appropriate time to express simple praise to our Lord.